Insights

Benefits & Accountability

Everyone agrees the health plan has to change. Most won’t change it.

WTW’s new survey puts 2027 trend at 11%. The bigger finding is the gap between knowing and doing, and that gap is a finance problem now.

· Brian Ullrich · EPIQ Insights

An unsigned signature page and unused pen on a slate-blue desk beside a closed binder, glasses, and an orange folder
Editorial illustration; not an actual plan document or survey.

Every fall the trend numbers come out, and every fall they get worse.

This year it’s three firms saying roughly the same thing. Mercer projects total health benefit cost per employee will rise 8.2% in 2027. [2] Aon says 9.5% before mitigation, pushing average cost past $19,000 per employee. [3] WTW’s 2026 Best Practices in Healthcare Survey, released November 3, puts medical trend before plan changes at 11.1%. WTW calls it the highest employer increase in more than two decades. [1]

You’ve probably seen those headlines. Here’s the part that matters more.

The gap between knowing and doing

In the same WTW survey, 49% of employers say significant changes to their health program will be needed within three years. A year ago it was 34%. [1]

Yet 56% say they aren’t willing to make disruptive changes. And 61% aren’t willing to take on the operational complexity that real cost cuts require. [1]

Read that again. Half the market knows the current approach won’t hold, and more than half won’t do what it takes to fix it.

That isn’t a benefits problem. It’s a decision problem. And it has landed on the CFO’s desk.

Finance is in the room now. Act like it.

WTW reports finance is getting more involved in healthcare decisions. In its survey, 78% say cost control drives their health strategy, and 68% say healthcare cost growth is outpacing their total rewards budget. [1]

Good. Healthcare is often a top-three expense line, and too many companies still treat it as an HR renewal event that shows up once a year with a number on it.

But “finance is involved” can mean two very different things.

It can mean the CFO gets the renewal deck two weeks before the effective date and approves the least-bad option. Or it can mean finance owns the model: the funding decision, the stop-loss attachment, the pharmacy contract terms, and the data that sits under all three.

Only the second one closes the gap.

Why “no disruption” usually means “more cost sharing”

When employers won’t make structural changes, the pressure doesn’t go away. It goes to the paycheck.

Mercer found that employers’ main short-term move in 2026 was shifting more cost to employees through plan design, and many dropped GLP-1 coverage for weight loss. That’s not a strategy. It’s a release valve. Done year after year, it shows up in retention, in benefits nobody can afford to use, and in a workforce that sees its deductible rising faster than its raise. [2]

The irony is that the “disruptive” changes most mid-market employers are afraid of are often less disruptive than another 8% contribution hike. Employees don’t notice a new PBM contract. They don’t feel a better-structured stop-loss policy. They don’t see a TPA audit. They do feel a $1,000 jump in the deductible.

What actually moves the number

WTW’s own data points to where the money is going: high-cost claimants, specialty drugs, chronic conditions and cancer care. Pharmacy alone is projected at nearly 27% of total spend in 2027. [1]

None of those get fixed by changing the copay on an office visit. They get fixed upstream:

  • Pharmacy contract terms. Definitions, rebate pass-through, spread, specialty carve-outs, audit rights. The DOL’s new PBM disclosure rule makes this easier to see. It doesn’t read the disclosures for you.
  • Funding and stop-loss structure. Is your attachment point right for the claimants you actually have? Are you buying lasers and exclusions you never priced in?
  • Claims data you can actually get. If you can’t see what your plan is paying, every other decision is a guess.
  • Advisor compensation. If your advisor is paid more when your premium goes up, ask yourself how hard they’ll push for a change that brings it down.

None of this is glamorous. Most of it is invisible to employees. That’s the point.

A simple test for your next renewal

Before your next renewal meeting, ask your team, or your broker, three questions:

  1. What did we change last year that wasn’t a plan design cost shift?
  2. What would 11% trend do to our budget over three years if we change nothing structural?
  3. Who in this room is paid more if the number goes up?

If the answers are “nothing,” “we haven’t modeled it,” and an awkward pause, you’re in the 56%.

The bottom line

The surveys aren’t telling you anything new about trend. They’re telling you most employers are about to repeat the same playbook and expect a different result.

The companies that get ahead of 2027 won’t be the ones with the cleverest plan design. They’ll be the ones where finance stopped approving renewals and started underwriting them.

If you want a fast, independent read on where your plan sits, our 30-minute Benchmark Read is a good place to start. Flat fee, no commissions, no production bonus. Just the numbers.

Get My 30-Minute Benchmark Read

Sources

  1. WTW: 2026 Best Practices in Healthcare Survey (November 3, 2026)
  2. Mercer National Survey of Employer-Sponsored Health Plans: Employers expect health benefit costs to jump 8.2% in 2027
  3. Aon: U.S. Employer Health Care Costs Continue Multi-Year Climb, Projected to Rise 9.5% in 2027 (August 20, 2026)
Benchmark Read